Thursday, June 23, 2011

The Heart Specialist; Claire Holden Rothman

Author: Claire Holden Rothman
Publication Year: 2011 
Publisher: Soho Press
Edition: ARC
Source: Amazon Vine
Date Completed: 6/19/2011 
Setting: Canada
Rating: 4/5
Recommend: yes

The Heart Specialist was an interesting read that caught my eye , and hooked me early on. I recently featured this book for one of my First Chapter, First Paragraph Tuesday Intros. In case you missed it, here was the how this book started out:

January 1882, St. Andrews East, Quebec.

" All morning I had been waiting for death, even though when I finally came the change was so incremental I nearly missed it. I had laid the squirrel out on a crate and covered it with a rag to keep it from freezing. Blood no longer flowed from the wound on its head, although it still looked red and angry. A dog or some other animal must have clamped its jaws around the skull, but somehow it had managed to escape, dragging itself through the snow to Grandmother's property, where I had discovered it that morning near the barn door. It had been breathing then, the body still trembling and warm. "
Although this book is a work of fiction, it is based on the life of Maude Abbott, one of Canada's first female physicians.  As the story begins, Agnes is only five years old when her father Honore Bourret, a famous doctor with a specialty in morbid anatomy (study of diseases) mysteriously disappears.  He was the center of a scandal in which his sister died. With their mother dead and their father gone, Agnes and her sister Laure are left to be raised by their grandmother, an aloof and woman, who did nothing to nurture the girls. Their last name is also changed from Bourret to White.

Even though Agnes was very young, she often watched with fascination as her father performed dissections in a special room in their home. Her biggest supporter of her interest in science and medicine is Miss Skerry, the governess, who told the grandmother that she has been watching Agnes, and she has "considerable gifts ."  At the age of fifteen, Agnes is sent to Smith's School in Montreal to study, and hopes to continue on to McGill to study medicine.  

The year, however, is 1898 and McGill's doors are closed to women. Even when supporters of hers help to raise large sums of money, for separate facilities to educate women at McGill, she is denied entrance. She ends up pursuing her medical degree at Bishop University, a competitor of McGill. After graduating Agnes is offered a job with pay at McGill's Medical Museum. Still faced with discrimination, her colleagues seem annoyed by her presence, because she is getting paid, but not teaching or doing research.

Even though Agnes made huge advances for a woman at that time, her life seemed unhappy because of her father's disappearance early in her life. One day that mystery begins to unravel when she discovers a misshapen heart, and other specimens have ties to her father's research.

There was a lot to like about this book. Although it was heartbreaking at times to see the struggles Agnes had to endure early on with both parents gone from her life. Those struggles didn't end with childhood. Because of the time period and society's view of women and their perceived roles, Agnes had to work twice as hard as most men to be taken seriously.  The writing held my interest pretty well, but at times the writing seemed dry and, for at least (50) pages I struggled a bit. Despite this, I am very happy I read this book, and think that many other readers will find it a inspiring read as well.


  1. I read something like this about female physicians in a series in the same period and the problems they faced and overcame. We have had it easy. This sounds a good book.

  2. I haven't heard of this one, but it sounds interesting.

  3. Agnes seems like an inspiring woman - to achieve success despite so many hardships is a thing which few can do.

  4. I loved that this is based on a real person and find the whole story intriguing.

  5. I like the sounds of this one and I'm also intrigued by the fact that it is based on read woman. I'll keep it in mind.

  6. I can't wait to read this one, so glad you liked it.

    It's my favorite type of book, hopefully I will get to it this summer.

  7. I'm sure I would like this book so thanks for the heads-up.

  8. Though at times it was a little dry, certain aspects of this book sound intriguing to me, and make me want to read this one. I am glad that you mostly enjoyed it and will be putting it on my list. Thanks for the great review!

  9. I had heard of this book but didn't know if I wanted to read it or not. Thanks to your review I'm adding it to my list.

  10. It still sounds like a book I would like to read even with the "dry" patch of writing. That first paragraph really grabbed me and your review has me itching to find out what's up with the father.

  11. This one sounds very enlightening. I don't think many of us really take the time to appreciate what our fellow women had to endure!!

  12. This sounds like an interesting read to me. Thank you for reviewing it.

  13. I've not heard of this one but am adding it to my wishlist. As a woman in the health care field it interests me!

  14. I am thankful that those women endured to open opportunity to those that came behind.

  15. This one sounds like something I would enjoy, I especially love that it is based on a real person. I'll have to keep it in mind for my sister-in-law who is about to become a nurse.

  16. The cover sure is eye-catching! The story sounds interesting too.

  17. This one sounds a bit strange to me. Not my cup of tea, I guess.


Thanks for taking the time to visit and double thanks for any comments. If you ask a question in your comments, I will try to reply to it here, or by email if your settings allow me to do so. Thank again for visiting.

(I apologize for the word verification, spammers spoil it for all sadly.)