The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake; Aimee Bender
From the title alone, I was thinking, "what could be sad about lemon cake, it's a favorite here". What if when you ate lemon cake, or any food for that matter, you could "taste" the emotions of the person who made it? Such is the case for little Rose Edelstein on the evening of her ninth birthday.
When Rose takes a bite of her mother's lemon cake with fudge frosting, Rose tastes sadness and despair. For Rose, this is not an isolated incident. She struggles to find foods that do not make her feel "hollow" inside. Baked foods are the worst, based on the mood of the person that baked them. Packaged foods seem to have less of an effect on her.
There is one incident where after Rose takes a bite of something prepared by her mother, she becomes hysterical from the bad taste in her mouth. She is rushed to the emergency room by her mother, and the scene she causes was, for me, laugh out loud funny. Rose's mother is not the only family member who has emotional issues. In fact, the entire family is pretty dysfunctional, and each is dealing with their own emptiness and emotional pain. Rose loves her brother Joseph, and she longs to be close to him, but he is a loner who has problems of his own. The father is detached, and in his own little world, and the mother is unhappy and has secrets of her own. There is even mention of a grandmother who never visits, lives alone, is somewhat gruff, and a grandfather who could read people by their smell.
This novel is actually kind of hard to classify, but it is very very good. The story is both funny and tragic. Rose is an excellent narrator, who seems much wiser than her years. The magical realism used by the author was very clever and, the writing style kept me engaged and anxiously turning pages to see what would happen next. If you are a fan of Sarah Addison Allen's novels, I think you will love this book as well.
RECOMMENDED - 4/5 stars (Review Copy)
LOL...I was thinking the same thing...what's there to bad sad about when it comes to cake, especially lemon! And then, like you, I thought of Sarah Addison Allen...I'll have to keep my eye out for this one!
ReplyDeleteInteresting concept. Lemon cake can be sour and sour can be sad. Glad you liked the book. So far I am on a roll with bad books. I am ever hopeful, guess that is why I keep reading LOL.
ReplyDeleteI love the premise you described. I'm not sure how I feel about combining lemon cake with chocolate frosting however!
ReplyDeleteI have been toying with the idea of buying this book for a while--now I think I definitely have to. Rats and also YAY!
ReplyDeleteI do hope my library has this book.
ReplyDeleteSometimes I struggle if there is too much magical realism in a book. Sometimes I end up feeling like I am just not getting it. But this one sounds like it has just the right amount.
ReplyDeleteI love lemon cake so this title amuses me. The topic sounds great and I am glad to see you really enjoyed it. I'll have to check it out!
ReplyDeleteI've read quite a few reviews about this book and they're all good stuff. I find the title interesting.
ReplyDeleteI've got to get my hands on a copy of this book! It sounds fabulous!
ReplyDeleteGlad to hear you enjoyed this one, Diane! Love the little crumbs in your review; think I'm going to need a bigger slice!
ReplyDeleteI kept thinking Sarah Addison Allen as I read your review and then you mentioned it and so did Softdrink. I think I will love this book!
ReplyDeleteThe first time I read about this book, I immediately requested it from the local library. I hope I am one of the first to obtain a copy when it is finally released this summer.
ReplyDeleteGreat review - and you have made me want to read it all the more.
I am really looking forward to reading this -- thanks for the review!
ReplyDeleteLemon cake with fudge frosting? Yeah, I'd have to agree that the person who made it was feeling a tad sad when she put that one together.
ReplyDeleteWhat an interesting premise for a novel. I had no idea what this book was about. I thought it was chick lit.
A lot of people bake when they are sad or depressed. I wonder what food would equate to happiness.
Your review has me intrigued about this one- baked goods that taste like the mood that the baker was in! Hmmm.....I'll definitely have to check this out.
ReplyDeleteI have been interested in this book since I first heard of it, but this is the first review that I have read. It sounds excellent, and I would love to get the chance to read it. It is a really unusual premise for a novel, but one that intrigues me! Great review, I am glad you liked the book!
ReplyDeletesounds fantastic :)
ReplyDeleteFrom your review this book reminds me a bit of Like Water for Chocolate, where emotions where transferred into food that was cooking. There may be something to that . . . .
ReplyDeleteTo me, that lemon cake looks divine! :)
My thoughts on Lemon Cake are very similar to yours.... that aside - i think that this sounds like a good concept for a novel - really interesting and strangely human despite being quite surreal -
ReplyDeletethanks for sharing
Hannah
I have this one on order and was wondering if I had made a wise choice. Now I can't wait for it to get here. I'm a huge Sarah Addison Allen fan, so if this book is even close to hers, I'll love it.
ReplyDeleteI think I'm going to have add this to the list ... and I personally don't like lemon cake so I can relate to the title! : )
ReplyDeleteSounds very much like, Like Water for Chocolate! I loved that book but would like to see Aimee Bender's take on something similar. Thanks for the great review!
ReplyDeleteBased on your review, I think I will really like this one. Putting it on my TBR list!
ReplyDeleteThat would be truly sad if you couldn't turn to food for comfort. Very interesting theme idea!
ReplyDeleteWhen you wrote that she could taste their emotions I immediately thought of Sarah Addison Allen's books. This one is a book that I must read!
ReplyDeleteA very original and unusual concept. Sounds like a good book.
ReplyDeleteI am glad you enjoyed this one, Diane! I've been waiting for your review as it's one I am considering reading. Looks like it'll be going on my wish list.
ReplyDeleteI've had this on my wish list for some time! I'm glad you liked it! I read a collection of stories of Aimee Bender that were bizarre and yet compelling!
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing!
I've been curious about this one. Glad to know you liked it.
ReplyDeleteI read my first Aimee Bender book last year and loved it. Now I need to read the rest of her books!
ReplyDeleteI just read this. Oh, my. It took me a few chapters but then I was hooked. Reading was better than listening, the author's voice was so monotone. The detail of the observation of life as it happens was amazing to me.
ReplyDelete